The Winner of the Real WTC Restoration
Design Competition is
ED SCHRAMLING DESIGN
by Ed Schramling of Columbus, PA
Thank you
to everyone who voted
Ed's model will be on display at the
Twin Towers Alliance Rally at the Central Park Band Shell in New
York City on Sunday, Sept. 10,
2006
Ed
Schramling Design by Ed Schramling of Columbus,
Pennsylvania
Ed Schramling is a 1937 graduate of Corry High
School of Corry, Pennsylvania. As a metal fabricator, Schramling
owned T. Ed Schramling in Columbus, east of Corry, and T.E.
Schramling in Corry. His company was the first to build the
Exerglide Swings in Corry's Mead Park and Columbus' Mather Park.
Now with all of the discussion about the Twin Towers and
whether to rebuild, Schramling feels no matter what design is used,
it is vital to the country to honor and remember what has happened
and the people who have died and suffered because of the
loss.
"I thought it should be remembered," Schramling said.
"It's the worse thing that ever hit the
country."
 |
 |
Eternal
Reflection by Benjamin Bakas of Chatham, New
Jersey
Benjamin Bakas is a Junior Architect who works for a
mid-sized residential firm in New Jersey. Bakas graduated with
honors from the New Jersey Institute of Technology with a Bachelor
of Architecture degree. Bakas’ father is a WTC survivor. He's a
civil engineer and worked at the Port Authority as a consultant from
Parsons Brinkerhoff who luckily escaped that morning.
What
really inspired Bakas to create this proposal was a sketch his
father did a few months after 9/11. He basically sketched the Towers
with this protective shell exterior wrapped around them...and the
facade reflectors at the reveal. He thought it would be extremely
powerful to reveal the facade in only one strip on each tower making
it sacred and special...making that space...the REAL memorial. Bakas
thought it would be a pleasant and emotional surprise when families
visit the facade to discover it's eternal reflection...along with
their own reflections.
Bakas feels the Towers NEED to be
rebuilt and that's the only thing that needs to be built there. NOT
the largest tower in the world, NOT some crazy exotic tower design
with 30 stories of gardens or windmills.... but the actual forms of
the Twin Towers themselves NEED to return. Bakas' father was the one
who told him about the Team Twin Towers competition. He thought...
Finally! A competition that would not only allow and encourage us to
rebuild the Twin Towers but make it a REQUIREMENT!
 |
 |
All One All Free by
Keith Edwards of Carlsbad, California
Keith Edwards graduated
with a Bachelor of fine arts (computer graphics) from San Diego
State University. He has been employed as art director,
photographer, designer, and draftsman. He is currently self-employed
as both a professional photographer and a graphic
Designer.
Ewards says, "On September 11th when the terrorists
attacked the United States they chose a specific symbol of our
society, "The Towers". The Towers have stood as a representation of
our strength, diversity, and achievements as a nation. For the past
five years I have been educating myself on the concept, design and
history of the towers and have embraced society’s attraction to
them. Elegant and massive, the towers portray the beauty of
simplicity - less is more. I believe that to rebuild in their
likeness would be a testament to our ability as a nation to overcome
tragedy as we have since the founding of this great land. Symbols of
honor and remembrance of a nation that came together when in need,
The Twin Towers should stand proud once again, representing the
truth in humanity and our unconditional love for both life and
freedom."
 |
 |
107th Floor by Christophe Hebert
of Versailles, France
Christophe Hebert is a French architect. One of
his interests in architecture was to express a feeling of
spirituality, a preoccupation about sense and
places.
Hebert’s proposal consists of technical and
typological solutions to make the rebuilding process possible. There
is a better space inside for corporate offices, organized as
villages of 8 floors (four double floors), linked by escalators and
served by double-deck express elevators from the lobby. Important
firms could have their private Sky Lobby at mid-level from
"villages." There is no more local elevators, which could not be
secured from basement in case of a major event. There is four
spread-out stairways and fire-fighter elevators, protected from fire
and smoke by fire-doors and pressurized vestibules. In case of
terrorism attack by jets, at least one or two groups of stairways
and FF elevators would not be affected. The structure is improved
from the original concept to be a technical solution to the 9/11
attacks. There is no more isolated columns, all the structure is a
coherent system Where, in case of major structural failure, forces
could be redistributed.Hebert feels the WTC rebuilding process is
not ordinary, that it's a very specialsituation to understand,
because of the grand emotional consequences. Hebert was inspired to
make his design from the point of view of safety, improved spaces
and living in a better world.
 |
 |
The People's Plan by
Robin Heid of Crawford, Colorado
Robin Heid grew up in
Colorado and was a US Army paratrooper before earning degrees in
journalism and political science. During the mid-1980s, he wrote
counter-terrorism commentaries and book reviews for the Rand
Corporation-based Terrorism, Violence and Insurgency Report. One
focused on the world’s worst pre-911 terrorist attack: The June 1985
bombing of Air India Flight 182 by Sikh terrorists that killed 352
people. His conclusion: the airline reservation network had enough
information to prevent the attack had the system been only
marginally smarter. His recommendation: It wouldn't take much to
make it smarter and "it would be crazy" not to do it. But it didn’t
get done and, 15 years later, Heid woke up to smoking rubble piles
where once had stood the world’s pre-eminent symbol of peace and
freedom and ever since then he’s worked to see the Twin Towers
rebuilt. Since then, he has committed himself to seeing the Twins
rise again - to include the creation of "The People's Plan,"
because, as Heid puts it, "what went down in dust and death must
rise again in steel and
hope."